Apparently I have no sense of style..?

Your style is a lot like mine! I love anything vintage, and thrift stores/vintage boutiques are my favorite. A lot of girls (mostly young) do not understand the style, because it's not what is " in " but it is a lot more clier than how most girls dress these days. It's good to have your own style, don't worry about what other people think. They are just followers and you are a trend setter! You sound very pretty, the eyes seem awesome!